At a glance
| Credit card | BMO Eclipse Visa Infinite | American Express Cobalt® Card |
|---|---|---|
| Annual fee | $120 (first-year annual fee waived) | $155.88 ($12.99 monthly fee) |
| Welcome bonus | Up to $60,000 BMO Rewards points and a first year waiver for the annual fee* | Earn up to 15,000 Membership Rewards® points in the first year (terms and conditions apply) |
| Earn rate | 5 BMO Rewards points per $1 on groceries, dining, gas and transit*; 1 point per dollar on all other purchases* | 5 Membership Rewards points for every $1 spent on eligible Drinks and Eats in Canada, including groceries and food delivery. Spend cap applies; 3 points per dollar on eligible streaming subscriptions in Canada; 2 points per dollar on ride shares, transit & gas in Canada; 1 point per $1 on everything else; earn 1 additional point on eligible hotel and car rental bookings via American Express Travel Online |
| Insurance | Emergency medical insurance*, common carrier, and car rental collision/loss damage coverage*; mobile device insurance*; purchase security and extended warranty* | Emergency medical insurance, travel accident coverage, flight and baggage delay, lost or stolen baggage, and car rental theft or damage protection; purchase security and extended warranty |
| Extras | Earn 10% more points when you add an additional cardholder*; $50 annual lifestyle credit*; Visa Infinite benifits* | |
| Read our review | BMO eclipse Visa Infinite review | American Express Cobalt review |
Welcome bonuses
The new BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card is an attention grabber, with one of the most generous bonus offers in Canada. New cardholders will get up to 60,000 points (a value of approximately $400 in travel rewards), a $50 lifestyle credit and the $120 annual fee waived in the first year - that's a $570 value in your first anniversary!*
Cardholders get 30,000 BMO Rewards welcome bonus points after spending a minimum of $3,000 in the first three months of opening the account. Cardholders also get an additional 2,500 bonus points in each subsequent month that you spend at least $2,000, beginning 4 months from the account open date and ending 15 months from the account open date (as long as your account is in good standing). The primary cardholder will get the $120 first-year annual fee rebated on the first statement and a $50 lifestyle credit. That’s a total value of nearly $570. If you cancel your card in the first three months, your welcome bonus will be revoked. BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card applications must be received by November 30, 2024 to be eligible for the welcome offer.
The American Express Cobalt® Card is also offering one of its most attractive bonuses ever. In your first year as a new Cobalt® Cardmember, you can earn 1,250 Membership Rewards® points for each monthly billing period in which you spend $750 in purchases on your Card. This could add up to 15,000 points in a year. That’s up to $150 towards a weekend getaway or concert tickets. Terms and conditions apply.
Winner: The American Express Cobalt® Card’s bonus is impressive. But it’s hard to beat a first-year annual fee rebate, which allows you to try out a card for a year without paying for it upfront. For that reason, the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card edges out for the win in this category.
Accelerated and standard earn rates
The BMO eclipse Visa InfiniteCard wows with some of the highest accelerated earn rates in Canada in an impressive total of four major categories. You earn 5 BMO Rewards for every $1 spent on dining (including take-out, delivery and meal subscription services like Hello Fresh), groceries, gas, and transit. The accelerated earn rate maxes out at $50,000 in annual purchases per calendar year. Once you reach this cap, the earn rate goes down to the regular rate of 1 point per $1 in purchases.
The American Express Cobalt® Card offers a similarly revved-up reward rate with 5 Membership Rewards points for every $1 spent at eligible eating and drinking establishments in Canada (spend cap applies). You also earn 3 points per dollar on eligible streaming services, 2 points per dollar on ride shares, travel and transit in Canada and 1 point per dollar on everything else.
Winner: The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card steals the show with a total of four (incredibly useful and spend-heavy) categories with a high earn rate of 5x the points per $1 spent. And keep in mind that, as a Visa, it will be accepted almost everywhere. The same unfortunately can’t be said for Amex.
Ease of point redemption
The BMO Rewards program is incredibly flexible, and you can redeem points for numerous rewards like travel (flights, hotel stays, cruises, and vacation packages), as well as gift cards, merchandise, and more. You can even apply points towards your BMO Investorline account. Best of all, it has a unique redemption option called Pay With Points that you can put directly towards a credit card purchase. The program is great because you can choose how many points you want to redeem toward a purchase and you can redeem them for as little as $1. That said, BMO Rewards do have one achilles heel: You need 150 points for $1 worth of travel rewards (a value of approx. $0.0067 per point) and 200 points for a $1 credit against your card statement (a value of $0.005 per point). Those are relatively low values for the points you earn.
The American Express Membership Rewards program is renowned for its ease of use, flexibility and array of redemption options like gift cards, merchandise, travel, streaming services, movie tickets and more. Its best feature? The MR points earned by the Cobalt card can be redeemed against a card statement for a rate of 100 points per $1 ($0.01 per point).
Winner: The American Express Cobalt® Card’s points are worth much more than BMO Rewards points. Cobalt card for the win.
Annual fee and APR
The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card has an annual fee of $120 that is waived in the first year. It also features an annual interest rate of 20.99% on purchases and a cash advance APR of 23.99% (21.99% for Quebec residents).
The American Express Cobalt® Card carries a $155.88 ($12.99 monthly fee) annual fee but it’s charged in monthly payments. It has an APR of 21.99% for purchases and a cash advance rate of 21.99%.
Winner: The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card takes this one. While the monthly charge for the American Express Cobalt® Card can be more manageable, the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card offers no fee in the first year for new cardholders, and its annual fee is lower overall than one year’s worth of combined monthly fees from the Cobalt card. That said, it’s worth noting that the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card has a very high annual interest rate for cash advances and the slightly higher interest rate could hit someone hard if they can’t pay off their monthly balances in full.
Insurance offerings
The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card features the following: mobile device insurance, extended warranty insurance, purchase security insurance, out-of-province emergency medical insurance, common carrier insurance, and car rental collision/loss damage insurance.
The American Express Cobalt® Card also has a well-rounded array of insurance coverage that includes: out of province/country medical insurance, flight delay insurance, baggage delay insurance, lost/stolen baggage insurance, hotel burglary insurance, car rental theft and damage insurance, travel accident insurance, purchase protection plan and buyer’s assurance plan (a.k.a extended warranty), and mobile device insurance.
Winner: The American Express Cobalt® Card features a much more comprehensive suite of insurance, particularly for travellers. The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card is missing some key coverages, like lost/stolen/delayed baggage, hotel burglary, and flight delay.
Referral bonus
Primary cardholders of the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card that add a supplementary card to their account (at a cost of $50 per card) will get a 10% bonus earn rate on their spending. This benefit is for transactions made both by the primary cardholder and any authorized users.
American Express has always been known for its outstanding referral program. With the American Express Cobalt® Card, cardholders could get up to a maximum annual referral bonus of 75,000 Membership Rewards points for referrals who successfully apply for the card.
Winner: The American Express Cobalt® Card outshines the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card because of its lucrative referral program and the fact that there is no cost for supplementary cards.
Other value-added features
The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card features one really nice extra: you can enjoy an annual $50 “lifestyle credit” which can be used for whatever you want.
The American Express Cobalt® Card offers cardholders a nice list of additional perks like benefits at over 600 hotels around the world and a hotel credit of up to $100 USD at eligible properties for things like the spa, golf, or dining. You may also get a free room upgrade. Another great, potentially game-changing feature is that points can be transferred to other travel programs like Aeroplan, Avios, and Bonvoy. Cardholders also get free supplementary cards. Finally, the American Express Cobalt® Card is part of Plan It™ – The American Express® Installment Program, which makes payments more manageable by allowing you to pay off a part of your statement balance in monthly installments.
Winner: Show me the extras! Quantity counts and the American Express Cobalt® Card has the most additional perks.
Program perks
The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card gives cardholders access to the Visa Infinite program. Visa Infinite members can enjoy things like exclusive invites to dining, hotel and entertainment experiences that are not open to the general public. Cardholders will also benefit from 24 hour, 7 days a week access to concierge services, as well as the Visa Infinite Troon Golf Benefit for discounts at 95 resorts and courses around the world.
With the American Express Cobalt® Card, cardholders are part of the American Express Invites program and can take advantage of things like special access to events, front of the line advanced tickets, exclusive dining opportunities and invites to special experiences.
Winner: The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card with its Visa Infinite Program is the winner because the program includes concierge service and is a boon for avid foodies and golfers.
Eligibility requirements and application process
The BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card features a quick and easy online application process. You will need a minimum $60,000 (individual) or $100,000 (household) annual income and cannot have declared bankruptcy in the last 7 years to be eligible to apply.
Applying for the American Express Cobalt® Card is also easy and can be done online in just a few minutes. Applicants will get a response in as little as 60 seconds. Even better, the card doesn’t have a specific income requirement, making it much more accessible.
Winner: The American Express Cobalt® Card, with no minimum income requirement, gets top marks.
Which card wins overall?
While the American Express Cobalt® Card has lots to offer, including high point redemption values, great transfer options to other travel programs, and a good suite of insurance, the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card comes out ahead with its generous welcome bonus, high-earning categories, lifestyle credit, widespread merchant acceptance, and flexible redemption options like Pay With Points. It’s also definitely worth reiterating that the BMO card is a Visa card and the American Express card is, well, an Amex card, and is not as widely accepted as Visa cards. If you’re a frequent flyer with Air Canada or British Airways, you might still consider the American Express Cobalt® Card, however, for those who aren’t, the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Card has most of your bases covered.
Recommended read: American Express Cobalt® vs Scotiabank Gold American Express.
- Terms and conditions apply
American Express is not responsible for maintaining or monitoring the accuracy of information on this website. For full details and current product information click the Apply now link. Conditions apply.
BMO is not responsible for maintaining the content on this site. Please click on the Apply now link for the most up to date information.
Read more
- World Mastercard or World Elite Mastercard - which is better?
- BMO vs. MBNA - which one is truly world elite?
Sandra MacGregor has been writing about finance and travel for nearly a decade. Her work has appeared in a variety of publications like the New York Times, the UK Telegraph, the Washington Post, Forbes.com and the Toronto Star.
Explore the latest articles
Best student credit cards in Canada
The best student credit cards in Canada are a great way to educate and reward students—without the income and credit score of regular credit cards.
Disclaimer
The content provided on Money.ca is information to help users become financially literate. It is neither tax nor legal advice, is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or to adopt any investment strategy. Tax, investment and all other decisions should be made, as appropriate, only with guidance from a qualified professional. We make no representation or warranty of any kind, either express or implied, with respect to the data provided, the timeliness thereof, the results to be obtained by the use thereof or any other matter. Advertisers are not responsible for the content of this site, including any editorials or reviews that may appear on this site. For complete and current information on any advertiser product, please visit their website.
